I resisted Harry Potter for a long time. The first book came out in 1998, but the series wasn’t on my radar for another two years or so. One night, I was babysitting the kids next door and they started to rave about it. Given that they were all in elementary school at the time, I chalked it up to a good way to keep kids interested in reading, but figured it wasn’t for me. I mean, a boy wizard? A whole other magical world? Muggles? Don’t be ridiculous.
Then, in the fall of 2000, I was on a plane to California for a cousin’s wedding and I realized that I had forgotten to pack reading material for the six hour flight. Fail. My mother saw this as her golden opportunity to force Harry Potter on me, as she’d been swept away by the stories, as well. After just a few chapters of Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, I was hooked. In a way, I felt lucky that I’d started the series later, because by that point the first four books had already been published. I could tear through them without waiting impatiently for the continuation of the story. Waiting is torture when you’re so engrossed in a plot – as I found out during the time between the fifth, sixth, and seventh installments.
I distinctly remember reading the fifth book on the beach; the sixth on a plane; and the seventh book over the course of about eight hours – all of them within a day or two of being published. And when the movies started coming out? I can’t begin to explain how excited I was. (I may or may not have seen the first one on opening night.)
But I confess: while I continue to be able to read the books over and over (and over) again, the movies have started to leave me slightly disappointed. I understand that it got harder and harder to fit everything into two hours – or even three – which is part of the reason why movie number seven is rumored to be released in two parts. But I cannot understand why it’s necessary to change the sequence of events or who said certain key lines. And there was something about the last movie, Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, that just felt off. I left the theater upset because my expectations were unmet and frustrated that the directors couldn’t see that they hadn’t stayed true enough to the original story.
I fear that the next movie, which comes out on Wednesday, will be another source of disappointment. I will see it. Don’t get me wrong. The trailers look phenomenal.
But I’m almost afraid to be even cautiously optimistic; I’m just plain cautious.
That doesn’t mean, however, that I don’t want to be pleasantly surprised. Plus, I still kind of wish that I could Apparate.


All I want in life is my very own Weasley.
Ah, to dream…
dood. i am a HUUUUUUUUUUUGE HP fan and I feel the same way
i’m hoping it’s ok, though. i’m waiting ’till it comes out on IMAX to watch it there.
WOO!
I don’t know if I can wait for that..sometimes I’m a little impatient. But…let me know when you go?
I am looking forward to the film. But mostly because I can’t remember for the life of me what happened in the books. And I know I read the darn things.
Each time I re-read I pick up on little things that I’ve forgotten. And I usually re-read right before the movie, but maybe I won’t now – so I won’t be as nitpicky.
True story: We rented the first Harry Potter film and both of us fell asleep. On waking up:
Him: Do you want to rewind it and watch the rest of it?
Me: Eh. You?
Him: Nah.
Fair enough; that was probably the least action-packed one of the bunch, so far.
Ive never read the books but I saw a couple movies. Are the books seriusly that much better?
Absolutely. The earlier movies aren’t terrible (I don’t think), but the books really just add more to the story. Plus, the books give you more Fred and George dialogue – always a plus.
I LOVE Harry Potter! Devoured all the books one by one and own all of them.
I’m actually going to a screening of it tonight and CAN’T WAIT TO SEE IT!
Excuse my nerdiness.
I might need you to report back tomorrow. Please and thank you.
I have so seriously been meaning to read the series for years; for years. But I’m ready now. Think I can read 7 books and see all the movies by Wednesday?
It’s an ambitious goal, to be sure. But I have faith.
You’re not trying to go to work at all, right?
Harry Potter, Lost, Mad Men, I resist getting sucked into cultural obsessions like these.
Because I know one day I’ll end up like you and it will suck all the time from my life.
I can’t speak to the others, but with Harry Potter, the books are worth the time suck.
The 19-year-old intern at one of my papers got me hooked on the books waaaay back in 2000. I too tore through the first four and then anxiously awaited each subsequent tome.
I didn’t buy the last one, my ex took care of that by being one of the folks up early waiting for the FedEx guy to deliver it to her door. I think she finished it in something like 11 hours (not much else happened that day). The funny thing was, a week after she turned it over to me, when she asked for it back so she could loan it to someone else, she was suprised I hadn’t finished yet. I took my time with Deathly Hallows, savoring each sentence like I was eating a delicious meal. And when the end came, with the Potters and Weasleys standing on the platform, I was full.
I’ve enjoyed them all and reread some once (or twice) and like you I’m looking forward to the movie this week.
I wanted to savor the Deathly Hallows – I did. But I really just couldn’t put it down. I know that some fans didn’t like how neatly J.K. Rowling tied everything together at the end, but I have to say, I didn’t mind it. I like the way you put it: I felt full as well.
I thought OotP was the truest to the book — or at least, in terms of tone. Sure, they had to cut a lot of plot, but I can’t read the book without this having this feeling of ominous dread, and I thought the movie conveyed that very well. I think it probably had something to do with the screenwriter — the regular guy wasn’t available, and the new guy was willing to take more risks. GoF was an awful adaptation, and if I’m nervous about HBP, it’s because the original screenwriter is back.
In terms of tone, I agree. And maybe I need to watch it again. But OotP is the one I remember feeling most disappointed with overall. I’ve always wondered if the outcome of a movie has to do more with the screenwriter or the director; I guess we’ll find out.
Movies never compare to the books!!